Lying in Morality and Practical Theology from the Viewpoint of Peter Kreeft

Document Type : Short Paper

Authors
Maryam Ardeshir Larijani 1
Abdollah Abedifar 2
1 Assistant Professor, Department of Ethics, Qom University, Qom, Iran.
2 Ph.D. Student of Ethics, Qom University, Qom, Iran.
10.30497/prr.2022.76207
Abstract
Practical theology can be defined as theological analysis and interpretation of social and cultural realities and especially human actions, providing suitable theological solutions to human life problems. Lying, as a moral challenge appears in various forms in daily life and needs deep attention. Peter Kreeft, as a Thomist, believes that sometimes lying not only is not bad but also it is permissible. Nonetheless, the circumstances under which lying is permissible can be known by intuition and conscience. Relying on Aristotelian-Thomistic rationalism, he criticizes the doctrine of nominalism, the philosophy of Descartes, and the philosophy of Kant. He claims that they have denied the intuitions of reason (as accepted in the philosophy of Aristotle and Aquinas), and have narrowed the realm of the reason so as a computer program. Nevertheless, the circumstances and intention have considerable importance in Aristotelian-Thomistic rationalism. In defending the permissibility of lying, Kreeft argues that circumstances, good intentions, and moral intuition are factors that can sometimes indicate the permissibility of lying. On the other hand, some objections have been raised to this view, one of which is that it contradicts the teachings of the Church and Catholic theology, and seems replaced the absolute truth in the teachings of Jesus Christ with moral intuition.
Keywords
Peter Kreeft
Kant
Lying
Moral Intuition
Aristotelian-Thomistic rationalism
Practical Theology
Ethics
انصاری، شیخ مرتضی. 1376. المکاسب المحرمة، ج. 2. دهقانی.
خمینی، روح‌الله الموسوی. 1410 ق. المکاسب المحرمة، ج. 2. اسماعیلیان.
محقق اصفهانی. 1409 ق. الاجارة. مؤسسة النشر الاسلامی.
نراقی، ملامهدی. 1379. جامع السعادات، ج. 2. اسماعیلیان.
Aquinas, St. Thomas. 1985. Summa Theologica, II-II. Christian Classics.
Augustine, Saint. 1952. Treatises on Various Subjects (The Fathers of the Church, Volume 16). Vol. 16. CUA Press.
Conte, Ron. 2011. "On lying, intrinsic evil, and moral intuition (reply to Peter Kreeft)." Accessible online at:
Kant, Immanuel. 1993.  Grounding for Metaphysics of Morals. Hackett Publishing Company.
Kreeft, Peter. 2011. "Why Live Action Did Right, and Why We All Should Know That." Accessible online at: < catholiceducation.org >
Kreeft, Peter. 2014. Practical Theology: Spiritual Direction from Saint Thomas Aquinas. Ignatius Press.
MacIntyre, Alasdair. 1988. "Whose justice? Which rationality?." In The New Social Theory Reader, edited by Steven Seidman, and Jeffrey C. Alexander, pp. 130-137. Routledge.
Vogt, Brandon. n.d. "Should you lie in order to prevent evil?" Accessible onlone at:
Philosophy of Religion Research
Volume 20, Issue 1 - Serial Number 39
The short papers published in this issue are in the field of Practical Theology.
July 2022
Pages 17-24