The Epistemological and the Methodological Foundations of Qāżī ʿAbd-Al-Jabbār B. Aḥmad and Abu Bakr Muḥammad ibn al-Ṭayyib al-Bāqillānī in Religious Knowledge: A Comparative Study

Document Type : Original Research

Authors
Ali Allah Bedashti 1
Seyed Hasan Saadat Mostafavi 2
1 Associate professor of Philosophy Department, University of Qom, Qom, Iran. (Corresponding Author)
2 Professor of Philosophy Department, Imam Sadiq University, Tehran, Iran
10.30497/prr.2017.1964
Abstract
As two Muslim thinkers, Qāżī ʿAbd-Al-Jabbār B. Aḥmad and Abu Bakr Muḥammad ibn al-Ṭayyib al-Bāqillānī agree on the possibility and necessity of the knowledge of Allah and the necessity of thinking and reasoning for knowing God. But they disagree over some epistemological and methodological principles. In this article, we will investigate some of these disagreements. The main differences between the two theologians in the epistemological foundations are focused on answers to questions such as whether reason or religion prove the necessity of the knowledge of God or whether the relationship between thought and knowledge is productive or implicative. Qāżī ʿAbd-Al-Jabbār defends the "rational necessity" of the knowledge of God as well as the 'productive relation' between thought and knowledge. He also believes the thought, as a human free action, to be the root of knowledge. However, Abu Bakr al-Bāqillānī defends the "religious necessity" of the knowledge of God and the "implicative relation" between thought and knowledge. Besides, based on the Ash’arite theory of acquisition, he believes that creation of knowledge is based on the power of creator. So, although two theologians are agreed on the validity of empirical, rational and religious methods in theology, they disagree over the degree of validity and priority of each of these methods.
Keywords
Qāżī ʿAbd-Al-Jabbār
Bāqillānī
Epistemological Foundations of Religious Knowledge
Methodological Foundations of Religious Knowledge
قرآن کریم
ایجی، عضد الدین. بی‌تا. المواقف فی علم الکلام. القاهره: مکتبة المتنبی.
باقلانی، ابوبکر محمدبن طیب. ‌1425 ق. الإنصاف فیما یجب اعتقاده، لایجوز اعتقاده، لایجوز الجهل به. بیروت: دارالکتب العلمیة.
باقلانی، ابوبکر محمد بن طیب. ۱۴۲۶ ق ( ۲۰۰۵ م). تمهید الاوائل و تلخیص الدلائل فی الردّ علی الملحده المعطلة و الرافضة و الخوارج. تحقیق احمد فرید المزیدی. بیروت: دارالکتب العلمیه.
بدوی، عبدالرحمن. 1388. تاریخ اندیشه‌های کلامی در اسلام. ترجمه حسین صابری. مشهد: بنیاد پژوهش‌های اسلامی.
رمضان عبدالله، محمد. ۱۹۸۶. الباقلانی و آراؤه الکلامیه. بغداد: مطبعة الامه.
شهرستانی، عبدالکریم. 1421 ق (2001 م). الملل و النحل، تحقیق امیر علی مهنا، علی حسن فاعور. بیروت: دار المعرفه.
صبحی احمد، محمود. 1405 ق (1985 م). فی علم الکلام. بیروت: دار النهضه العربیه.
عبدالجبار. بی‌تا، المغنی فی أبواب التوحید و العدل. تحقیق ابراهیم مدکور. ج 12. بی‌جا: بی‌نا.
عبدالجبار. ۱۴۱۶ ق (۱۹۹۶ م). شرح الاصول الخمسه. تحقیق عبدالکریم عثمان. قاهره: مکتبة وهبه.