Religious Realism vs. Anti-realism: Revisiting Don Cupitt, Paul Badham and D. Z. Phillips

Document Type : Original Research

Author
Ali Sadeqi
PhD Student of Philosophy of Religion, Institute for Humanities and Cultural Studies, Tehran, Iran.
10.30497/prr.2016.1847
Abstract
Realism/anti-realism controversy has always been crucial in the history of philosophy, so that it has affected all philosophical areas, including religious belief, in which admitting realistic/anti-realistic approach has a wide range of influences in all religious concepts. After shedding some lights on preliminary issues concerning the nature and kinds of formulation of realism/anti-realism controversy, the present study is aimed at analyzing and comparing two kinds of Anti-realism: Don Cupitt’s one which relies on his reading of modern philosophy (especially Nietzsche’s), and D. Z. Phillips’s one which uses Wittgenstein’s later philosophy of language. Based on these foundations, they end with elimination of metaphysics and lead to one kind of relativism. So, application of these views on religious belief leads their attention to practical aspects rather than conceptual and theoretical ones. At this very point, Paul Badham, on the contrary, believes as a realist that performing rituals and prayers, in the absence of religious notions would be impossible, and having a realistic approach to the one who is worshiped (namely God), is an inherent part of religious practices. Finally, we show that these kinds of Anti-realism face with the problems which are insurmountable. Also, we will show that Badham’s Realism is not strong enough to cope with Ani-realism
Keywords
Religious Realism
religious anti-realism
relativism
Cupitt
Badham
Phillips
رورتی، ریچارد (1394)، «مخالفت با روحانیون سیاسی مسیحی و انکار وجود خدا»، در آینده دین و خدا در مسیحیت، ریچارد رورتی و جیانی واتیمو، ترجمۀ کاوه حسین‌زاده و ناصر نصیری، تهران: علم.
مالکوم، نورمن (1383)، دیدگاه دینی ویتگنشتاین، ترجمۀ علی زاهد، تهران: گام نو.
ویتگنشتاین، لودویگ (1383)، در باب یقین، ترجمۀ مالک حسینی، تهران: هرمس، چ 2.
ویتگنشتاین، لودویگ (1384)، «سخنرانی دربارۀ اخلاق»، در از مدرنیسم تا پست مدرنیسم، لارنس کهون، ترجمۀ عبدالکریم رشیدیان، تهران: نی، چ 4.
ویتگنشتاین، لودویگ (1389)، پژوهش‌های فلسفی، ترجمۀ فریدون فاطمی، تهران: مرکز، چ 5.
Alston, William (1995), "Realism and the Christian faith," in God, Reason and Religions, New Essays in Philosophy of Religion, Eugene Thomas Long (ed.), Springer Science+Bussiness Media Dordrecht.
Anselm, St. (1973), Prayers and Meditations, Harmondsworth: Pinguin Classics.
Badham, Paul (1993), "The Religious Necessity of Realism," in Is God Real?, Edited by Joseph Runzo, St. Martin’s Press.
Cupitt, Don (1990), Creation Out of Nothing, SCM Press.
Cupitt, Don (1993a), "Anti-Realist Faith," in Is God Real?, Joseph Runzo (ed.), St. Martin’s Press.
Cupitt, Don (1993b), "The Religious Adequacy of Non-Realism," in Is God Real?, Joseph Runzo (ed.), St. Martin’s Press.
Cupitt, Don (2001), Taking Leave of God, SCM Press.
Eshleman, Andrew S. (2005), "Can an Atheist Believe in God?," Religious Studies, 41.
Le Poidevin, Robin (1996), Arguing for Atheism, Routledge: London and New York.
McGraw, Clare (2008), "The Realism/Anti-Realism Debate in Religion," in Philosophy Compass, Vol. 3, Issue 2.
Moore, Andrew, and Michael Scott (2007), Introduction of Realism and Religion, Philosophical and Theological Perspective, Ashgate Publishing Limited.
Murphy, Nancy, and Brad J. Kallenberg (2003), "Anglo-American postmodernity: a theology of communal practice," in The Cambridge Companion to Postmodern Theology, Kevin J. Vanhoozer (ed.), Cambridge University Press.
Phillips, D. Z. (1993a), "How Real is Realism? A Response to Paul Badham," in Is God Real?, Joseph Runzo (ed.), St. Martin’s Press.
Phillips, D. Z. (1993b), "On Really Believing," in Is God Real?, Joseph Runzo (ed.), St. Martin’s Press.
Trigg, Roger (2010), "Theological Realism and Antirealism," in A Companion to Philosophy of Religion, Charles Taliaferro, Paul Draper and Phillip Quinn (eds.), Blackwell Publishing Ltd.
Williams, Rowan (1979), The Wound of Knowledge, London: Darton, Longman & Todd.
Wittgenstein, Ludwig (1967), Wittgenstein Lectures & Conversations on Aesthetic, Psychology and Religious Belief, Cyril Barrett (ed.), University of California Press.